| Platinum | Brooklyn Pickle |
| Gold | Mello's Subs |
| Silver | Jersey Mike's Subs |
| Bronze | Piggy Pats Smoke & Ale House |
| Top Pick | Arby's |
| Top Pick | Castlewood Cafe |
| Top Pick | Hot Off the Brick NY Style Pizzeria and Deli |
| Top Pick | Jimmy John's |
| Top Pick | Rosa's Italian Bakery-Deli |
