| Nominate Nominated! | Big Jay's |
| Nominate Nominated! | Charlie's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Franco's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Franco's Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Grandes Holland Patent |
| Nominate Nominated! | Hot Off the Brick NY Style Pizzeria and Deli |
| Nominate Nominated! | The Hub Eatery |
| Nominate Nominated! | Lukins Brick Oven Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Mangia Macrina's Wood Fired Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Nina's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | North End Pizza & Tap |
| Nominate Nominated! | O'scugnizzo Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | O'Scugnizzo's Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Oliveris Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | One Genny |
| Nominate Nominated! | Parkway Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | The Pizza Box |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizza Boys |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizza Plus |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizzeria Italia |
| Nominate Nominated! | Poppa G Restaurant |
| Nominate Nominated! | Ramons Bakery |
| Nominate Nominated! | Rosario's Pizzeria East Utica |
| Nominate Nominated! | Tony's Pizza & Deli |
| Nominate Nominated! | Tony's Pizzeria & Deli |
| Nominate Nominated! | Tony's Pizzeria-Burrstone Rd |
| Nominate Nominated! | Two Brothers Cafe and Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Venice Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Westie's |
