| Platinum | Nina's Pizza |
| Gold | Knuckleheads Brewhouse |
| Silver | Symeons Greek Restaurant |
| Silver | Zeina's Cafe & Catering |
| Bronze | 7 Hamlets |
| Top Pick | Bossones |
| Top Pick | Brooklyn Pickle |
| Top Pick | Georgio's |
| Top Pick | Griffin's Pub |
| Top Pick | Joey's@307 |
| Top Pick | Lafa Meditereanian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Willows |
