| Platinum | Nina's Pizza |
| Gold | Big Jay's |
| Gold | The Hub Eatery |
| Silver | Venice Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Franco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hot Off the Brick NY Style Pizzeria and Deli |
| Top Pick | O'scugnizzo Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | O'Scugnizzo's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Pizzeria Italia |
| Top Pick | Tony's Pizzeria & Deli |
