| Platinum | Utica Coffee Roasters |
| Gold | Calabria Coffee |
| Silver | Yummilicious Cafe & Bakery |
| Bronze | Sheri's Eastside Diner |
| Top Pick | Florentine Pastry Shop |
| Top Pick | Good Life Cafe |
| Top Pick | Joseph Putrello Coffee Barista |
| Top Pick | Poppy's Place |
| Top Pick | Rosie's Oriskany Diner |
| Top Pick | RoSo's Cafe and Catering |
